i didn’t jump on the harry potter bandwagon until after the fifth novel was published. it’s one of those things i kinda sorta regret, but not for the reasons you suspect (or don’t suspect).
in tenth grade, i belonged to my high school’s literary criticism club (i use the term “club” very loosely). basically, my ninth grade english teacher ms. berner invited a few of her “favorite” (i use that term presumptuously) students to take the UIL (one of those state-run academic/athletics organizations) literary criticism exam, which tested one’s knowledge of the handbook to literature, a book (different every year), and the poems of a single poet (different every year). after the exam, we’d have lunch, which was pretty much the purpose of the invitation. she (and we) didn’t care about the test; we just wanted to have lunch together.
that year, the chosen book was harry potter and the sorcerer’s stone. because ms. berner had such strong, negative reactions to that “novel” having been chosen, i didn’t read it (did not even bother to watch the movie). instead, the night before the exam, i focused all my energy on cramming the entirety of the handbook to literature into my spongy brain. let it be known that i am an insanely good crammer, and i missed all of two friggin questions on the handbook to literature section (which is awesome). and i did really well on the poetry section (i think that year was the poems of william wordsworth). however, i completely bombed the book section and did not place among the top students.
my friend kate, who was and has always been a big harry potter fan, scored higher than i did (which is not to say that she should’ve have…i mean, the girl is brilliant). no one from our school’s team went past the first round of testing and we all went to lunch. i think we had tex-mex that day, which makes me feel better in retrospect.
point is, had i read the first of the harry potter series, or had watched the film, i would’ve done really well on that exam, and i would’ve been able to put that on my college application, which wouldn’t have mattered anyway because i got into the college of my choice, but still, i’m just saying…
anyway. last friday night, the significant other and i saw harry potter and the half-blood prince, which i thought was quite good. in light of the revitalized harry potter mania, i think it’s time that i rank the books in order, according to my preference (of course). as you know, i love making lists (maybe after the last two movies come out, i’ll rank the films, too).
spoiler warning: if you haven’t read the books, step away from the computer. and go read the books.
7. harry potter and the half-blood prince: i can see why the sixth novel in the series is well-liked by some people. for me, though, it’s a boggy mess. there isn’t enough structure to the storylines; they kind of just meander, that is, until we learn about the horcruxes. then the last 100 pages go at full-speed and are, admittedly, amazing. however, the last couple of action-filled chapters do not make up for harry being at his most annoying, sulking about in the halls of hogwarts, obsessing over draco malfoy’s every move. seriously, those first hundreds of pages are agonizing…yeah, i’ll say it: nothing. happens!
6. harry potter and the chamber of secrets: i read in an interview with j.k. rowling, right before the release of the final installment of the heptalogy, that the second novel held some keys to the conclusion of the series. of course, she was referring to tom riddle’s diary (and the basilisk venom), which we later find out is the second horcrux. and though i find chamber of secrets to be heavy-handed and didactic at times, i cannot deny the importance of this book in the series. here, we get some of lord voldemort’s backstory, which is endlessly fascinating (tom marvolo riddle=”i am lord voldemort”!).
5. harry potter and the sorcerer’s stone: the novel that started the craze, sorcerer’s stone is our generation’s lord of the rings, charlie and the chocolate factory, alice in wonderland, even. who didn’t want to attend hogwarts school of witchcraft and wizardry after reading the first book? who didn’t imagine what house they would’ve been sorted into (i think of myself as a wizard in the house of ravenclaw)? who was disappointed to find himself/herself a mere muggle?
4. harry potter and the deathy hallows: the final installment of the heptalogy is thrilling, heart-stopping, tragic, triumphant, and ultimately,
quite satisfying. it’s a perfect novel up until the end, when i get the impression that rowling wrote the last eight or nine chapters with a gun to her head. i recently reread the book, and i liked it less than the first read. the final battle is interrupted twice—twice!—by long, expository passages: snape’s past and redemption, harry’s meeting with dumbledore at king’s cross station (blah blah blah). though the book is not the best in the series, there are numerous brilliant moments: the chapter “malfoy manor” is genius, kreacher’s story arc is wonderful, the chapter with the silver doe is haunting…i can go on and on. moreover, the writing here is top-notch.
3. harry potter and the order of the phoenix: i read this behemoth of a book (it’s the
longest in the series, coming in at 870 pages) in like, two days. i even called in sick to work just so i could finish the giant novel in peace. i love so many things about this installment: the first dementors attack, the introduction of dolores umbridge (that character is so divine, so deliciously evil), dumbledore’s army, the O.W.L.s, the centaurs, luna lovegood, the death of sirius black (sad, i know). i find that order of the phoenix really takes the series into a deep, dark place only hinted at with books three and four. speaking of which…
2. harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban: the ingenious sequence with hermione’s time turner is enough to catapult this installment into the top three. with the introduction of escaped convict sirius black, the soul-sucking dementors, the werewolf remus lupin, and the prophecies of sybill trelawney, prisoner of azkaban marks a considerable departure from the first two books in its tone. dark and ominous is the atmosphere at hogwarts, and harry must learn how to defend himself. one of my favorite spells of the series is the patronus charm, and when harry performs it successfully at the end of the book, i actually weep because i’m so overwhelmed (the stag, his father, the words ”expecto patronum”).
1. harry potter and the goblet of fire: the middle installment is the best structured, the most complete, the most imaginative, the most fun of the seven-part series. written around the framework of the triwizard tournament, goblet of fire is the only book with a specific beginning and end—and what an end. harry finally comes face to face with present-day lord voldemort, and blood is spilled (not just harry’s, but cedric diggory’s too!). what’s most fascinating about that graveyard showdown is the reverse spell effect, priori incantatem, which occurs when the two opponents’ wands connect. that, ladies and gents, is horrific and magical stuff.
in book four, not only do we meet a slew of new characters (including international ones), but we also follow harry in a number of contest-related adventures: capture a golden egg guarded by a dragon, save a loved one at the bottom of the black lake, secure the triwizard cup in a magical (and dangerous) maze (my favorite of the three obstacles—it features a sphinx!). rowling juggles the quest for the championship (an adventure story) and the dark stuff (more of a mystery) deftly. she kinda makes you forget that the teenage wizard has to save the world eventually…sprinkled about the novel are significant clues to lord voldemort’s impending arrival: the unforgivable curses are introduced, the dark mark in the sky at the quidditch world cup, the missing barty crouch. oh, and there’s a yule ball, where hermione gets pissy. it’s all here, in harry potter and the goblet of fire.
agree? disagree? what, you think i’m too old to be writing about this? i know many of you will defend half-blood prince. perhaps i’ll give it a reread when i return home in two weeks. it’s probaby a better read second time around and plus, i know it’ll probably enlighten me.
it’s kind of sad that there are no more harry potter books coming out. the series is over. and i am not going to read twilight.